Buy the Best Carpet: Best Options and Best Brands
June 2, 2023, by: Jamie Sandford
This week we aim to help you find the best carpet, taking into account quality, budget and style, and offer up expert recommendations and reviews of the top carpet brands.
Whilst it is true to say that hardwood flooring remains the most popular type of flooring for most home buyers, the fact that carpet still has an important share of the flooring market means that it is definitely worth considering for your home.
Related Reading: Where to Buy Hardwood Flooring
Indeed, more and more people are also keying into the practical and aesthetic appeal of having a mix of flooring types in the home – using hardwood, tiles and carpeting in different rooms depending on function and style.
You can also click here for our advice on carpet buying, installation, prices and cleaning.
There are a number of reasons to considering carpeting a floor, but the main one is of course the added, softer comfort of carpet material underfoot.
Carpets give a warmer, snugger feel to a room and so are particularly popular for bedroom floor and playrooms; they also provide better soundproofing than hardwood or tiles, which makes carpets a good choice for home gyms, home cinemas and offices.
Carpets also often conjure grown-up luxury; there is a certain air of “high maintenance” about a carpet that makes it seem like the kind of choice only rich people make!
But of course the best kind of carpet combined with the right kind of stain protection in place is just as easy and inexpensive to maintain as any other type of floor. So let’s get into all the detail to help you buy the best carpet for your home.
WHAT’S THE BEST CARPET OPTION FOR YOU?
So of course the first decision to make in your quest for the best carpeting is the color and style that you want to complement your room. The color will be a personal choice based on the design of your room – but bear in mind that for resale purposes it’s usually best to keep carpets neutral, as boldly colored or patterned carpets are often too personal, and you want to appeal to as many people as possible if you’re selling your home.
The style of carpet you choose will depend to certain extent on the lifestyle you lead and how you use your home. Carpet style refers mostly to how the fibers are woven onto the backing. There are five common carpets styles each with their own qualities as follows:
Saxony (aka Plush)
Best for formal settings, velvet-like soft surface, very luxurious, but will show up vacuum tracks and footprints quite easily so fairly high maintenance
Good for high traffic areas, durable and doesn’t show up dirt, footprints or vacuum tracks as much. Learn more about textured carpet and cut pile carpets.
Friezé (aka Twist)
More informal, like a short shag style, excellent for kids and for hiding vacuum tracks and footprints. Check out our frieze carpet post outlining pros and cons and the best brands.
Looped (aka Berber)
Most formal, not entirely ideal if you have kids or pets as can snag more easily, but easy to clean. Read more in our Berber carpet guide.
Sculptured (aka Cut & Loop or Pattern)
Good for families, hides dirt better than other styles, but patterns can feel dated quite quickly
WHAT MAKES A GREAT CARPET?
Once you’re decided on the style that best suits your home and family, the next thing to consider is exactly what factors determine the quality and durability of a carpet.
The main factors to consider are the type of carpet fiber used and the fiber density. Have a look at our article about carpet ratings for detailed analysis of these factors.
But in brief, the best carpet fibers such as wool, nylon (or a wool/nylon blend) have a much better reputation for durability and resilience. If nylon is treated with stain protectors then, like wool, it is also very easy to keep clean.
Other man-made fibers such as olefin and polyester have some good aspects that make then suitable for certain areas such as playrooms, but aren’t good for elsewhere, so less appealing overall.
As for density, effectively the better the density the better the quality. You also want to look for carpets that have at least 40-oz of fiber per square yard – this is known as the face weight – to increase the longevity of the carpet; and also check the tuft twist rating – a minimum of five twists is best.
Finally, remember that any carpet you buy is only as good as the under carpet padding you get with it and getting a qualified professional to install it is highly recommended!
BEST CARPET COLORS & TRENDS
Whilst most of us will want to make sure our home décor is keeping up with the latest styles and trends, laying a good quality carpet can be a costly investment, so it’s best to make sure that you choose a look that is classic and adaptable so that it will have maximum longevity whatever décor aesthetic you go for.
However there are some new carpeting trends for 2016 that you might want to consider depending on your budget.
Gray & Taupe Neutrals
The good news is that the dominant neutral theme from last season, using a palette of grays and taupes, is still popular this season.
Muted Blues & Earthy Greens
If you want to try to be a bit more daring you might also consider other colors such as blue, teal or green, but keep it all muted, soothing and natural. So no bold, bright azure carpets any time soon!
Adding to the earthy feel, opting for a highly textured carpet is also on trend right now; for the best of all worlds look for really chunky Berber style carpets that are both cozy and chic!
Cut and loop style carpets that allow for an inherent pattern in the weave are big for 2015/206; but to stay on trend make sure the pattern is geometric or randomized (not floral!). Discover more about floor patterns.
Shaped Carpet Tile
Following on from patterned carpets, if you really don’t care about longevity and simply crave the WOW factor, then the real hot designer trend this year is the amazing new contemporary takes on carpet tile such as Hadi Teherani’s take using innovative shapes and material to stunning effect (see above).
Related Reading: Popular Carpet Trends
REVIEWS OF THE BEST CARPET BRANDS
The carpet brands reviewed below should give you a solid base from which to start your research before buying the right carpet for your home and budget. It is not an exhaustive list but we do cover the most popular and well known carpet brands.
DuPont is one of the world’s largest chemicals company, and has a strong history of developing innovative products including synthetic fibers that are used in numerous industries including carpet manufacturing. To be clear, DuPont do not make their own carpets, but supply their trademarked fibers to carpet makers who then produce the carpets.
For many years DuPont’s textile fibers division was synonymous with their Stainmaster fiber, but this division and the Stainmaster brand was sold off in 2004 to the Koch Industries and renamed Invista.
DuPont then went on to develop a new biopolymer called Sorona, which is being used by major carpet manufacturers including Mohawk (in their SmartStrand and SmartStrand Silk carpets) and Godfrey Hirst (in the eco+ carpet range).
Sorona is essentially DuPont’s brand of triexta fiber which at its base is made from glucose extracted from corn; this makes the start point of the fiber renewable and sustainable; the processes involved in creating the end product results in a very soft, permanently stain resistant carpet. Opting for a carpet that uses DuPont Sorona fiber is a very good choice especially for families and for areas of high traffic.
This seemingly relative newcomer on the block – its parent company was created in 2009 – is actual steered by a very old hand! The company was founded by none other than Bob Shaw, formerly CEO and member of the founding family of Shaw Industries! It seems that Bob Shaw might have found retirement a little dull, and so returned to his roots to create another massively profitable flooring company, Engineered Flooring LLC!
Dream Weaver is the company’s carpeting brand, and boasts an impeccable manufacturing pedigree – made in the heart of Georgia in one of the largest productions plants in the USA.
Specializing in nylon and polyester fiber carpets, Dream Weaver offer a huge range of styles and colors, all with stain protection and lifetime stain and fade resistance warranties. We particularly like that their proprietary PureColor solution-dyed fiber means that the color runs right though each fiber, giving excellent fade resistance and depth of color in every strand.
And frankly, the impressive rise of Engineered Flooring LLC to become on pf the major flooring industry players in just 10 years means they must be doing things right! Read our in-depth Dream Weaver carpet review.
Lifeproof carpet is one of Home Depot’s exclusive carpet ranges. It is actually manufactured by Mohawk, so you have the added confidence of buying a product from a trusted manufacturer (see below).
Lifeproof carpets main selling point, as you may have guessed from it’s name, is durability. It is made from fibers that give it exceptional stain resistant qualities.
However, that isn’t the only selling point for this carpet brand. With around 150 different products in the range there is plenty to choose from in terms of style and color.
Furthermore, prices range from between $1.78 per square foot to $6.09 per square foot making Lifeproof carpet affordable for nearly every budget.
Customer reviews have been on the whole been very positive. If you would like to know more plead read our in-depth Lifeproof carpet review.
It’s no wonder that Shaw Floors are the market leaders when it comes to carpeting in the USA. They have an absolutely HUGE offering of carpets, matching every possible style, design and use you could ever imagine! Whether you’re after an on-trend chunky Berber or a simple and classic cream plush carpet, you’ll find it at Shaw Floors.
A quick browse of their website is all you need to do to realize just how enormous their carpeting ranges are: the carpet shown below is just one color option of the 24 options in the All At Once carpet design (this shade is Soft Fleece, by the way), which is just one of the 43 designs in the Caress collection.
Shaw Floors also offer their highly praised, patented R2X carpet stain and soil protection on most of their carpets; and their Caress range of carpets are made with their premium Anso nylon fiber that comes with a 20-year warranty. Read our Shaw Lifeguard carpet review.
The other major player in the US carpet industry is Mohawk, who first started producing carpets in 1878! Their longevity can only be explained by their constant willingness to keep up with trends, search out innovation and work with talented design teams.
Mohawk is also keen to promote investment in environmentally responsible production as evidenced by the large offering of products made with recycled and renewable resources and are “dedicated to running our business in the best way we can, and to making a positive impact in our communities”.
It’s also worth noting that since 1878 Mohawk has developed into a large corporation which, over time, has incorporated other well-known carpet brands such as Karastan, Bigelow, Lees and Durkan. But all that really matters for most folk is that Mohawk do have a very, very large range to choose from, all treated with “gold standard” Scotchgard Advanced Repel Technology products. Read our Mohawk carpets review.
Beaulieu America Bliss Carpet
Since its humble origins in 1978, Beaulieu America was once the third largest flooring manufacturer and the largest carpet-only maker in the world. Sadly, they company filed for bankruptcy in 2017 and its assets were bought by Engineered Flooring LLC.
However, their highly-regarded Bliss carpet brand is still available from some retailers with both wall-to-wall and carpet tile options, in either nylon, polyester, polypropylene or nylon/ polypropylene blends.
With 81 designs to choose from, each available in upwards of 10 colors, there is a lot of choice and variety. Plus, some of their carpets are available with added benefits like their Magic Fresh odor reducing treatment and their Silver Release antimicrobial treatment.
But for us, the best thing about the Bliss collections is that they really straddle a whole range of design aesthetics and colors: there really is something for everyone here.
What we also like is the carpet tile options – though usually thought of as a commercial product, some of the designs (like Planx shown below) would be more than suitable for residential spaces such as the “man-cave”, games room, gym or home cinema.
The Milliken group is a huge, multilayered corporation that offer innovative solutions in several areas including chemicals, industrial and specialty textiles, and floor coverings.
It’s this last one that we care about! Their residential carpets are currently arranged in three excellent collections: Imagine, Crystal Stitch and Hardanger.
But you’d be mistaken in thinking that wasn’t very much choice… the Imagine collection alone has 71 different designs! And boy are they different – there are classic block color designs, cool contemporary geometric patterns, elegant pretty floral, bold animal prints and patterns that you simply won’t see anywhere else!
Patterns like the neat five pointed stars on the Allegheny design, the hexagonal tiles on the Modern Flair design and the plaid checks on the Greyfriar design.
Milliken carpets are made with nylon and New Zealand wool blends, using a high definition patterning technology to ensure that their carpets are both beautiful and durable.
You would think that such a strong name would give rise to bold, brash, heavy duty style carpets, but the range of carpets at Tuftex are nothing like that! In fact they offer a very sophisticated range of beautiful designs that are just the right side of being fashion-forward whilst remaining classic and classy.
With currently 155 designs to choose from, most of which come in a large choice of colorways (upwards of 20 colors in most designs) there’s plenty to choose from.
Personally, we think what Tuftex do best are patterned carpets, like the Tracery design shown below, their patterns are mostly geometric and not too overpowering, making them an ideal backdrop to complement your home décor.
And the good news is that Tuftex is now part of the Shaw Floors corporation, so you get the same high quality fibers and stain protection that you expect from all Shaw Floors carpets.
Karastan is perhaps one of the more interesting carpet manufacturers that have been incorporated into the Mohawk Industries group. For a start, they are able to make the very bold claim that they played “a big part in introducing American households to the very concept of walking in comfort”, by being the first American manufacturers to create a loom that could handle the kind of design detail usually woven by hand!
Of course, their most renowned products are their premium area rugs; but their range of carpet are also very much worth looking into.
What we like about Karastan is the great diversity of their ranges, going from traditional Persian style carpets, via contemporary geometric patterned carpets and all the way to super bold animal print carpets!
Being part of Mohawk also means that many of Karastan’s carpets are made with the SmartStrand biopolymer carpet fiber from DuPont which combines the benefits of renewability without sacrificing high performance. Read our Karastan carpet review.
Godfrey Hirst Carpet
One of the largest and oldest carpet mills in Australia, Godfrey Hirst is now recognized as one of the world’s top carpet manufacturers with retail points across the USA and Canada.
Specializing in wool, wool blends and polyester carpets, they offer both classic luxury and family friendly carpets to suit most traditional and contemporary decors. The general design style is quiet elegance with subtle patterns and muted, neutral tones, though some of the polyester carpets are available in shades of blue.
Comparatively speaking some of Godfrey Hirst wool carpets retail at the low to mid range point ($3-$5 per square foot) which makes them an interesting option if your heart is set on wool.
Currently with a total of 402 carpets to choose from, their easy-to-use caret search facility on their website has options such as color, pile type, fiber and price point to help you drill down to find the right carpet for your home.
They also have a very handy Carpet Calculator on their website to work out exactly how much you’ll need!
If you’ve got a great budget and are looking fro a beautiful, quality wool carpet then look no further than Fabrica. Originally part of the Dixie Group of carpeting mills, which has now been partly acquired by Shaw Floors, Fabrica are one of the few top mills producing carpets made with 100% New Zealand Wool.
There are currently 21 different carpet designs available in wool most of them featuring subtle geometric patterns.
Among our favorites are: Paragon – a perfectly sophisticated chunky Berber loop carpet (available in 30 different colors from pure Lily white to dramatic Black Out; the elegant basket weave design of Bon Ton (pictured below) which comes in 17 different colors; and the pretty pin dot pattern of Petit Point which is available in 16 colors, including lovely, muted on-trend Sea Grass and Cadet Blue.
However, if you like their classic and fairly traditional styles, but don’t have quite enough budget to stretch to wool, Fabrica also have an extensive range of nylon carpets. Read our full Fabrica carpet review.
We love the ethos at Paradiso: they “don’t believe that luxury is defined by fads that come and go—and it’s certainly not defined by a price tag.”
The result of this way of thinking is that Paradiso have a comprehensive range of elegant and tasteful carpets, many of them available at affordable prices. And when we say comprehensive range, we really mean it. Paradiso currently has 54 different carpet collections, with lots of color options in each collection, amounting to well over 300 different individual carpets!
There is certainly something to suit all tastes, from textured block colors to leopard print patterns, chic geometric motifs to classic floral designs; and in a variety of carpet types and manufacturing processes including cut & loop, cut pile or flat weave, hand loomed and woven.
Note that Paradiso keep their costs reasonable by offering not only 100% wool carpets but also carpets made with synthetic fibers and wool blends. Of course, different fibers have different levels of durability, resilience and so on. Be sure to consult with your Paradiso retailer to ensure that the carpet fiber you choose will suit your home and lifestyle. Read our full Paradiso report here.
And finally, if you’ve got little kids and love the idea of creating a unique bedroom or playroom just for them, then have a look at the super cool made to order wall-to-wall carpets at Kidcarpet.com.
Whether you want to go for an education alphabet and numbers carpet, or for a theme like the Buzzy Bugs, the School of Fish or the Woodland Wonders, there is a great choice of brightly colored, beautiful carpets for you (personal favorite is Up And Away) who can resist walking on clouds!). There are also fabulously bold, block color carpets – in the kinds of bright and happy colors you can’t find at a “grown-ups” carpet store.
As you would expect from carpets made for kids, these carpets are super durable and fire rated. But they have also been really well thought through design-wise. For example, they deliberately steer away from using yellow or other light colors in their designs, as these colors tend to show up dirt quickly!
Another good tip is that along with their huge range of kid friendly area rugs, most of their wall-to-wall designs are also available as area rugs!
Hopefully we’ve helped you find the best carpet for your home flooring needs. Please do share your carpet investment and installation experience in the comments section below.
About the Author:
Jamie Sandford is the Owner and Chief Editor of Home Flooring Pros (find out more). After 12 years’ experience in screen and stage set construction, followed by a further 15 years working in the home renovation/remodeling business, he now writes and curates online home improvement advice.
“Buying and installing home flooring should be a fairly straightforward process, but often it isn’t. After more than 15 years experience in home flooring and remodeling, I started Home Flooring Pros in 2013 to help homeowners navigate the often-over complicated process of choosing, buying and installing a home floor. The aim is to save you time and money by helping you to make better floor buying decisions.”
2 thoughts on “Buy the Best Carpet: Best Options and Best Brands”
Set a Budget
While the first thing that homeowners usually think about when shopping for bedroom carpeting is the color and texture, determining your budget is probably the most important step in the entire process. Carpeting prices depend on the square footage of the room, so be sure to measure your space before going to the store. If you have a large master bedroom, you may need to look for less costly options. If your bedroom is on the smaller side, however, you may be able to splurge on luxury carpeting since you’ll need less to cover the room. Either way, once you have a firm budget in mind, you’ll save time at the store because you’ll know which carpets you can afford and be able to more easily identify the highest quality options within your price range.
Does Resista Soft Style shed or have any other negative qualities?